
I was a movin’ man in my younger days
But I gone out my ramblin’ ways
I left that road so far behind
Now I know, oh babe
I got mine…
~The Black Keys
The sun’s coming down as I dip off the interstate, long rays nicking off of the Challenger’s endless nose. The sheet metal, dipped in retina-snatching Inferno Red Crystal Pearl, seems to stretch on indefinitely toward the horizon, and the 5.7-liter V8’s sonorous tone bounces through the open windows to sing back up with The Black Keys. Under normal circumstances, I’d down the volume as I approach the stoplight, but I’m in a Challenger, and I haven’t felt this bad ass since perfecting the J-Turn in high school. I stop next to a Grand Caravan and the mom behind the wheel instantly scrambles to up her window. The kids in the back are glued to the glass, eyes the size of dish plates, soundless “wows” escaping their lips. I tap the throttle to get the 372 horsepower mill to bark just once as the light turns green and the kids go wild. Mom arches her eyebrows in spite of herself. Kowalski would be proud.

The 2009 Dodge Challenger R/T is a funny bird. Bigger, heavier, more expensive and more comfortable than the other neo-muscle competitors out there, the car seems to ooze confidence. By now we’ve all read the reviews. We know even the mighty SRT-8 fails to stack up against the sinister Chevrolet Camaro SS or even the underpowered Mustang GT in all the ways a sports car can be measured. But this ain’t no sports car, kids. This is Detroit muscle in the biggest way. It’s not the fastest, but it’s mammoth proportions are larger than life and damn good looking in the flesh – the kind of mean styling you don’t mind walking away from in the parking lot. “Oh that? Yeah, I’m driving it.”

Dodge seems to have penned the Challenger with an eye toward recreating that adolescent moment when scads of the American youth first laid eyes on their uncle’s car back in the ‘70s. You can’t help but feel small as you approach it, thanks largely to the epic 197.7 inch length and 75.7 inch width. The car. Is. Huge. From its squared off, recessed grille to the bulging rear hips, the Challenger simply exudes size, and that girth is a nod to the original. The dish-plate headlights and turning indicators are genuinely cool, as is the bar tail light out back. We’ve also got to give credit to the 18-inch wheels on our tester. They’re big, but not ridiculously huge 20 inch steam rollers.

More than a few auto journos have berated the Challenger for its interior, but the truth is it’s not a bad place to spend time. The black-on-black-on-black theme is about as bright and cheery as sticking your head in a paint bucket, but the seats are comfortable and supportive with serious bolsters, and the soft-touch dash nice, if nothing else. The bland styling is clearly a shot to the original car, so we can only fault the designers so much. The four-spoke steering wheel is a tad bulky for my tastes, but fits well with the car’s overall ham-fisted theme. My only real qualm comes with the location of the turning indicator and cruise stalks. They seem to be placed unnaturally low on the column, and for the first few days with the car I was left fumbling in thin air. I also have to question the location of the emergency brake. You won’t find the hoon’s favorite hand brake in this sucker, it’s a pedal-activated unit. We miss the temptation.

The Challenger benefits from some serious gusto, even in mid-level R/T trim. The 5.7-liter Hemi V8 dishes out 372 horsepower and 400 lb-ft of torque and in our tester it was coupled to a 5-speed automatic box, though a six-speed manual is also available. A locking diff out back makes sure every ounce of that power makes it to the ground. Thought the 5.7’s power pales in comparison to the SRT8’s mighty 6.1-liter, complete with 425 horsepower and 420 lb-ft of torque, it’s still more than enough to hustle the Challenger along.
Pages: 1 2



You hit the nail on the head… great review.
I love this car and would take it over the other two muscle cars in a second… (it would be a manual SRT8 though, of course)
We are used to seeing Mustangs all day everyday…
The Camaro is certainly cool, but we have seen those for years as well.
The Challenger represents an era that you and I missed out on. Cruising the boulevard in something loud, big, and eye-catchingly American.
I got more looks in the Challenger that I reviewed, than I did in an Aston Martin Vantage or a Nissan GT-R…
I was gassing up a car two nights ago and a black Challenger pulled up at the pump next to me. The owner was so happy to talk about his car (he owned a 1971 as a younger man), and the passion was evident. I was standing next the Audi R8 I was fueling… and the conversation stuck with the Challenger.
(though, the rest of the station was staring at the R8…)
Thanks, Jeff. It’s true, I’d rather have the six-speed SRT-8 myself, but for some strange reason you can’t get it in white. And mine would have to be white…
Sorry, that interior is unacceptable. Awful.
It’s not that hard, in fact it should be DAMN easy, to recreate a stylish and functional interior. Can Detroit not find a single designer with some taste and sense of style? Giant bulky buttons and plastic…sweet Jesus, the plastic. Spend an extra three bucks and get some metal in there. How nice would a nice, clean three spoke metal wheel be? How much more would it add? How could a huge car company miss this?
It’s in the details people. This is why no one wants US muscle. They HAD the details back then. Now…it just seems everything falls just short. I for one will not pay 30K for falling short.
Hey Chris. All I can say is give the car a drive. You might be surprised as I was. The interior really doesn’t translate that well in the photos. True, there are a few things that could use improving, but all in all it was well executed.
You charming anecdote highlights my problem with this car: people give you thumbs up, nostaligize about the Good Old Days, and your Stoplight Moment of Glory came from impressing minivan occupants.
It’s a total poseur-mobile, the Hummer of muscle cars. The performance/dollar is just way too low.
If I wanted nostalgia, poor handling and pseudo-quickness from a bygone era, I’d buy a real classic.
For my money, I’d buy a used GT500. If it’s gotta be a new car, I’d buy a track-pack equipped Mustang GT.
I agree with you that this car is 100% image…but it is a pretty awesome image. If the marketers expect actual performance buyers to look at this car they’re nuts.
I’m sorry I mocked the Challenger…please get back to posting!
Haha. No worries. Just got back from playing with a new toy in Detroit!
Would you say you’ve been keeping your schedule Flexible?
I’d say I hopped up to join in on a game of Lacrosse.
You know what that means in Canada?
Not really a team sport (hopefully).
i like the car bro